DOG HEARING - PUBLIC HEARING- Tuesday, May 18th, 2025 Ms. Nagle, Ms. Chase vs. Ms. Ducharme Mr. von Bleicken: These are the ground rules and process for this nuisance/dangerous dog hearing. All individuals involved or participating in this hearing will be sworn in under oath. Complainants and their witnesses, defendants and their witnesses. I'm going to ask first, that the animal control officer, we have animal control there? The, animal control officer and former animal control officer, she's the former. So we only have. Just to be clear, we only have the former right here. Okay. For the town of West Brookfield to speak and provide any facts that have on the events that have led, up to this hearing. I will then ask members of the police department, to provide the, relevant police reports, the complainant and any of the complainants' witnesses will be asked to speak and maybe ask the questions from the board. Then the defendant and any of the defendants' witnesses will be asked to speak and maybe ask questions from the board. All individuals speaking must state their name for the record. No one may speak unless the individual has been recognized by the chair. There will be no conversation or direct cross-examination between the complainants and the defendants. Any questions between the opposing parties will be directed, through the chair. Either side may ask questions of the other after the selectmen have completed their questioning. Each side will be given the opportunity to present rebuttals or excuse me, or concluding remarks following the concluding remarks, the hearing will be officially closed and no more remarks from either side will be allowed. The board will deliberate and open session as to the findings of facts. The board will make a decision as to the actions that will be taken. Do both parties understand? Ms. Chase: So a decision will be made tonight as to what's going to happen when you say that that is yes. Mr. von Bleicken: That's the plan. If you intend to speak as a complainant, defendant or witness, please stand to be sworn in under oath. Resident (Mr. Murphy?): I'm sorry, but I can't. Mr. von Bleicken: That would include police officers. Let's raise your right hand. Mr. Merkel: You gotta get everybody's names. Mr. von Bleicken: Yeah. I'm going to ask after the oath if I can get everyone's name, please. Mr. von Bleicken: I will swear in all witnesses wishing to speak to all speakers wishing to testify. Raise your hand. We already did that. I swear. And you are to say I so swear or something there. Thereby, I swear that the testimony I'm about to give is the whole truth and nothing but the truth. Excuse me. All: I swear, I swear. Mr. Merkel: So may I have your name. Brid Murphy Mr. Merkel: I'm sorry? Slow down. Ms. Murphy: B r i d M u r p h y Mr. Merkel: Okay. Ms. Nagel: Roberta R o b e r t a, Nagle N a g l e and sometimes it will be Robin as it's another name, but my real name is Roberta. Mr. Merkel: Okay. Richard Murphy Louise Chase Mr. Merkel: L o u i s e? Yes Mr. Merkel: You said Chase? Yes. Mr. Merkel: C h a s e ? Yes Thank you. Mr. Merkel: Ma'am? Addie Ducharme. Mr. Merkel: You said Addie? A d d i e You said Murphy? I'll spell it. Mr. Merkel: Ma'am? Leah Shattuck L e a h S h a t t u c k Mr. Merkle: I know you guys (referring to both police officers, Sergeant Matt Letendre and Officer Cassidy Culver). Mr. von Bleicken: Okay, so. One minute Okay, so, we would ask that we would start with the complainant. Ms. Cofske: You were going to start with the former ACO then, then Police Department. Mr. von Bleicken: Police Department. Oh, correct. Correct. But, let me find the correct order. This is my first hearing, so bear with me. Where is this? Yeah Okay. Right. So, I first ask the animal control officer and former, well, the former animal control officer for the town of West Brookfield to speak and provide any facts that, they have on the events that have led up to it. Ms. Shattuck: Sure. Let me start by saying that I know there is a history last year with this dog, I don't know the facts because Kat took those calls, but there are at least two that I know of from two to other incidents with this time. Mr. Sickenberger: Two other instances? Ms. Shattuck: I'm fairly certain, she's (referring to Kat Klein)not communicating with me at this point, so you would need to clarify that with her. I don't want to say they were probably, it was literally almost a year ago. I'm going to say like maybe, May/June, because it was just as I was leaving and she was stepping in. Okay. Actually, Louise Chase might have more details about the month. Ms. Chase: Mine was in May. Ms. Shattuck: So I was called out to, and I don't remember the address, but Long Hill Road to your residence, for a dog that had attacked a dog. When I got there, the dog that had been attacked was gone and Matt was here. You were here (referring to Officer Culver). We were at the end of this person's driveway, and the dog was pretty close to the end of the driveway. I know up on the hill in the turn, but, you know, fairly close. It's a big dog. It's a Great Pyrenees. I had a Great Pyrenes for 11 years and I loved him, but they're not friendly to strangers. So, Matt was just saying, "We'll just walk right up there." And I said, no, you know, we're not going to walk away. And, he was doing his job. He was barking and he was on his own property by now. Meantime, Mrs.Ducharme was yelling at us in the road. Matt was trying to talk to her. She wasn't having it. I tried to talk to her. She wasn't having it. The dog was across the street barking, going down the street, and she was kind of following it. It wasn't. I have a video, actually, and a picture. The dog had a huge thing of blood on the side of his neck. I did see the dog that was attacked later. They came back by and it was a substantial... They will tell you this, but I think it was about that big. It was a substantial gash on that dog. I don't know what you do when the person that owns the dog isn't trying to reel that dog in and say, "I'm so sorry. This will never happen again." I mean, he's he's dangerous. And it's not his fault. He's doing his job. He doesn't understand where his property boundaries are. He thinks he's protecting all that road. You know, he thinks that's all his land to protect. And, so it's not really his fault, but he's he's a danger. I really feel like he would hurt someone certainly. I mean, if she had reached in to that dog fight, you know, with dogs or bites people really hard in a fight because they don't know what they're biting, you know, they think they're biting the other dog. They don't mean to bite the person. But I mean, it could have been substantial damage. I don't know how she got the dog off of her dog without getting hurt, but, it definitely is really concerning. Mr. Merkel: Do you have a video? Ms. Shattuck: I do, let me. If you want to go to someone else, I can dig it out. It was a little while ago. Sergeant Letendre: It was 2/17. Ms. Shattuck: Okay. Mr. Merkel: And I know this is kind of a standard question, but like you said, she was not having it. What do you what do you mean by that? Ms. Shattuck: She wasn't listening to us. She was yelling at us, telling us it was our problem, that I was acting that way because we are in the street in front of the property. And that's not true. You have to control your dog. It doesn't have to necessarily be on a leash, but it has to be under your control at all times. And if it's going off the property and barking and not and and it's just classic great Pyrenes and just I'm going to keep going. bo bo bo down the street, you know. that's very typical of pyrenes. and you know, I'm going to keep going. But she just wasn't instead of being apologetic and concerned, she just was yelling. I haven't a little bit of it.(referring to the video) I'll find it. Mr. von Bleicken: Okay, while you're doing that, we can move on to the police officers. And so who was there? So you were there? Sergeant Letendre: She basically explained it how, you know, with us, except for we got there before she was there. We were there when the victims were there with their dog. It was bleeding on the back of the neck. Could have had a big gash. I, I took, we took down their information. We told them we would deal with the other dogs, get this dog to the vet, you know, to get it care as soon as possible. They had left. We tried calling the ACO Kat Klein and like, every other time, no answer. You know, voicemails are left. We never get phone calls back. Nothing. It's a waste of time. So I called Leah and she came out and helped us. When she was coming out, Mrs., Ducharme had pulled her vehicle up. It was really windy that day, so me and Cassidy get back in my cruiser so we didn't get hit by any the branches falling, and the vehicle had pulled up to the top of her driveway, and I got out and started yelling towards her, and she had left. She had walked back towards her house, so I had dispatch call the house to tell her to come back down and talk to us, and the dog came walking down and had a huge red all around. I mean, it's a white dog. Red sticks out like a sore thumb. So the dog started coming down towards the road, not in the road, but it was still on her land. Mr. Sickenberger: So, which dog? Sergeant Letendre: Big white one. Her one. Mr. Sickenberger: Great Pyrenes? Ok. Sergeant Letendre: So we walked over, to start to go up the driveway to try and get ahold of her. And the dog started barking like, getting on. And the next thing you know, he's sitting next to her car and stuff like that. But let's walk back. And that's when Leah showed up. And I think that's kind of the same thing happened. They said, oh, let's, let's take a walk up there. I said, you know, it's probably not mean or whatever. And yeah, we weren't convinced that. So that's when Mrs. Ducharme came back and she was yelling a lot. I tried to calm her down and like, listen, my body here, because I want to be here, you know? You know, we had a call, two dogs are fighting, you know, and we have to deal with it. And she just didn't want to hear. Kept yelling. Her dog at that point went out into the road, went across the street. That's when Leah had got in her car. I think she was recording it. And then Mrs. Ducharme came back, and after Leah left, Mrs. Ducharme completely calmed down. You know, talk to me. I told her what was going on. At that point, she was perfect, you know, listening to everything I had to say. I told her who who was involved,and she's like, oh, my God, you know, those are my neighbors. And and everything was good. And I told her, I said, so, it's all going to be documented, you know, through a report and, maybe to reach out to your neighbors, apologize, whatever, try and make things better. I said there's probably going to be a hearing. They said there could possibly be a hearing, I think, and here we are. And then, the second call I got was on, February 22nd. That was whatever a week later or so. About that dog being a distance away from their property, in the fields, I believe, is how it was described on, Long Hill Road. At that time it didn't go after the victim, but she was scared of it because of past issues she's had with it. So I documented that one as well. And again, I called Kat Klein and no answer. So I called Leah. Ms. Shattuck: I have the pictures. Do you want it? Mr. von Bleicken: Please, thanks. Ms. Shattuck: They're not long. You can just take my phone and you guys can share it. Mr. Merkel: So, do you have the report piece officer? Ms. Shattuck: It's that one, that one,that one, that one, that one. And then the stills. If you zoom in, you can see the dog. You know, mean. And. Mr. Sickenberger: Oh, that's not a dog. (speaking with Mr. von Bleicken, looking at the phone) Mr. von Bleicken: She said past it. Mr. Merkel: You might have to hit the ball and blow it up. Ms. Shattuck: I think I turned the volume down so that I wouldn't disturb you guys. Mr. Sickenberger: I just locked it by accident. Ms. von Bleicken: I'm glad I asked him to do it. Ms. Shattuck: That's a video. Mr. Sickenberger: That one particular because, listen. You can watch in the square. I can't really see or hear, are you just walking up to the dog at that point? Ms. Shattuck: She's trying to catch the dog. Yeah, that's probably the last one you guys clicked on. Mr. Sickenberger: That's how we do things usually. Okay, let's see if there is another video. Ms. Shattuck: Do you see the dog? Ms. Ducharme: I'm sorry, what? I'm not chasing it. Ms. Shattuck: Okay, here's the dog across the street. Mr. Sickenberger: Oh, wow. Ms. Shattuck: That's about it. I mean, there's a few more, but they're similar to that. Mr. Sickenberger: Do you have any pictures of the injured dog? Ms. Shattuck: I didn't take pictures. They were taking it to the vet and they just stopped to show me briefly. You can show some. (motioning to Ms. Nagle) Mr. Merkel: That's not the second (referring to second dog incident). Second one's not in there. Mr. von Bleicken: All right. So, we'll then move on to the complainant and any of the complainant's witnesses, who want to speak. Who wants to begin. Ms. Chase: I will. Mr. von Bleicken: So can you state your name, please? Ms. Chase: Chase. I just want you to know this is not a dog fight. It's an attack. Also, its happening on public property. On the road. I'm sorry, I'm a little nervous, emotional about it. To me, it's very dangerous, serious situation. I would like to read the statement that I had to write up for court because we did have to sue her, unfortunately, not that we wanted to do that at all and want to get it figured out. So I'm going to read that, if you don't mind. I was going to read part of it, but I'm going to read the whole thing. Because just through this discussion, I want you to know what happened and how serious this is and frightening it is. And then I have a couple of bullet points I'd like to say, too. So this happened here. So description of events. May 6th, 2024 around 11:45 p.m., I was walking my leashed 45 pound hound dog along the road as we approached the defendant's yard, but we're in front of the neighbor's yard. I noticed the defendant's Great Pyrenees type dog in the neighbor's yard. The dog suddenly came down the neighbor's driveway and onto the road behind us without any warning, and pounced on my dog, flattening her to the ground. It was biting my dog and she was screaming in pain. I started yelling for help and tryied to kick the dog, who didn't pay any attention to me. I was afraid it was going to kill my dog. The defendant and the man came running over from the dog's property. The man grabbed the dog and after a couple of tugs was able to haul the dog off of my dog. He dragged the dog up the driveway to his house. My dog scampered to the other side of the road and was shaking and whimpering. I crossed over and the defendant joined us. She apologized many times and asked if my dog was okay. My dog's back was all wet, but I didn't see any blood and she was crying in pain and wouldn't let me look at her. The defendant acted very concerned and apologetic. She gave me her name and number. We talked about how her dog is often loose but has never bothered us before. She said it's a guard dog and protects her chickens. She thought it might have been protecting them. We seem to have a good rapport and she said it was nice to meet me as she went up her driveway. My dog seemed okay, and was able to continue the walk home. She was still shaking and wouldn't let me look more closely at her, so I let her rest for a while. In the meantime, I texted the defendant to ask if her dog was up to date on shots. She texted right back to say their dog is up to date and again, how she's sorry and she hopes my dog is okay. After about an hour, I checked again and discovered blood on my dog's leg and back. She let me push back her fur and I discovered bite marks. I called my local vet who said I should immediately bring her to emergency surgery. I called another local vet and they recommended the same thing I called veterinary emergency specialty hospital in South Deerfield and they said to bring her right in. My husband and I left immediately. The hospital is over an hour's drive. After a few hours wait, we were told that our dog would have to spend the night. We got back to the car and my husband called the defendant. He told her that the injuries were serious and needed stitches. She said she didn't think it was so bad. He said that she should keep her dog tied up. She said she didn't have to listen to this and hung up on him. After a few minutes, he called back and left a message saying that he hoped we could talk civilly about this issue and that her dog should not be loose. The next morning, my husband drove to the hospital to pick up our dog. I texted the defendant and again emphasized that the last thing we want is to be at odds with the neighbor, and that we hope to work something out as we now have a vet bill. She texted back to say that she thought I was 100% wrong, and any further contact should be mailed to her address. I also notified West Brookfield Dog Officer Our dog had stitches in her leg and back and a drain in her side to prevent infection from internal tears. She had multiple medications, had to wear a cone, had to be closely monitored and very restricted activity. She had two follow up visits to remove drain and remove stitches. Because of this attack, we had to cancel the long awaited vacation. I'm afraid to walk past their house, a walk I've been doing for years. I have since seen the dog loose and because of the negative attitude of the defendant, I worry that she won't keep the dog tied up and we will be attacked again. So, then we sued her. Okay, six months later she did pay. Then I have a couple of bullet points. So again I'm emphasizing this is not a dog bite. It is an attack. There's no there's no fight going on. It's...My dog's totally passive. It's a dog attack. It attacks with no warning, no growl or bark. It just appears and pounces, sinks his teeth in and start to maul. I thought my dog was going to be killed in front of my eyes. This dog shouldn't have more rights than law abiding taxpaying citizens. This is a road I've been walking for years. My dog's on the leash. I love my road. I shouldn't be afraid to go out my door. Tying the dog up is no longer an option. The owner had that opportunity for almost a year and has ignored repeated directives to do so. They have allowed the dog to continue to roam at will and terrorize at will. Here comes springtime, people will be jogging, riding bikes and walking their grandchildren along that road. It's a very rural area and Robin will tell you there's nobody around. Houses. The few houses that are there are set back from the road. There's nobody there. The other side is state property. There's there's nobody around. This is the last thing I think I want to say. This is a horrible situation. I don't hate that dog. I don't hate the dog. The owner created this situation. She didn't take care of it after the first incident. She didn't take care of it after the second incident. I hope you won't allow a third incident to occur. The dog needs to be euthanized, I'm sorry. I shouldn't feel guilty about that. It's. It's a safety issue and it roams all over. If it stayed on its property, it stays on its property. It's not staying on its property. It roams a half a mile. Who knows where it goes. But I don't like when I had to call 911 back in February, it was at least a half a mile and I just saw it going through the woods and I was scared. Now I walk with an axe handle, people telling me I need bear spray. I'm just trying to go out, enjoy nature. Mr. von Bleicken: Oh do we do we have any other? Mr. Merkel: So question should for you. For a year you've been walking on since the first time you've come across this dog before when you were talking, walking your dog or is this just the first time it came at you? Ms. Chase: First time came at us. Mr. Merkel: How many times prior to that have you walk your dog and never had an interaction with this animal? Ms. Chase: Many times. Mr. Merkel: Many times? Ms. Chase: Yes, and it stayed up in its...I never thought it was going to be dangerous. It stayed up and it's uphill driveway. Watch us walk by. Mr. Merkel: Was this the first time you walked by and it was on its neighbor's yard? Ms. Chase: I'm sorry, what do we got attacked? Mr. Merkel: Yes, the day of the attack. Ms. Chase: It was on. Its on its neighbor's property. Mr. Merkel: Across the way? Ms. Chase: No, there are no houses across the way. Just to the side. Mr. Merkel: Just to the side. Ok. Ms. Chase: Yes. It came down the neighbor's driveway onto the road and attacked my dog. Mr. Merkel: Thank you. From behind? Ms. Chase: From behind. Yeah. Mr. Merkel: No warning, nothing? Mr. No warning. Nothing. Ms. Chase: And because I'd been by the dog number times before, the dog can never come down the driveway. Mr. Merkel: You weren't worried? Ms. Chase: I wasn't worried, but that attack happened so fast and was so strong and powerful. And I sprained my foot kicking it, trying to get it off. And when I saw, I don't know, if it's her husband. I don't know who he is. It took him a couple of tugs to get that dog off. That dog is scary, dangerous. No, maybe it's sick. I don't know, I don't know. All I know is it's dangerous. It's loose. They make no effort to tie it up. And you can't see the house from the road. So she might say, oh, yeah, I'm tying. I know it's not tied up because I have pictures on my phone of it being loose. I have called Kat a number of times, and finally I did have to call 911. The first time I've ever called 911. And certainly the first time I've ever had to sue anybody. I don't want to do that. We tried to work it out, you know, practically a neighbor would have been nice to work it out, but. But the dog is dangerous. Mr. von Bleicken: Do we have anyone else who'd like to speak on. Ms. Nagle: Oh, thank you. So my name is Roberta Nagle. And on February 17th, I was walking down the driveway of 263 Long Hill Road. And I take a left on Long Hill Road and similar to what Louise said, all of a sudden the dog is on top of my dog. There's no barking, there's no print, there's nothing. Except in one minute I'm walking the dog and the next minute the dog is under the grasp of this very large white dog in the middle of the road on a very cold day and, rolling on the ground. The dog is known as Luna. It is owned by Addie Ducharme. Aggressively attacked my dog. My dog's on a leash. Just going for a walk like we usually do. I'm on the road. I'm not on anybody's property. So she pushed her to the ground and held her there. My dog weighs 47 pounds. I do not know how much this dog weighs, but I would expect it's a good 60 pounds more than her. Nothing. Nothing predisposed to it. Chewing on her back, her neck, her shoulders and her ears repeatedly. My dog was, um, continues to do this for an extended period of time. I'm trying to get her off Orla. And, she is a large dog. Like I said, it's impossible for to to help her let go to help her let go. Thus, she cut Orla and drew much blood. I did think that she was dead based on the gravity of this experience. And, I was yelling for help. There was no response. It's as we said, it's a very rural area. And, then, eventually she got off. I called 911. One of the officers responded, my husband and my daughter came down. I relayed the details of the attack to the officers. And then, the assistant, the animal control officer did come later. We took the dog to the VCA Wickaboag, which is our veterinary clinic. There was extensive damage to the dog. It was all cut up. Just those areas that I mentioned. And, the veterinarian, Doctor Pollard examined the dog along and knows the dog, our dog very well, and said, this has to go to this...The suggestion was can't go to Tufts. He called ahead. We immediately brought the dog to Tufts. She had surgery, she went under for wound repair, under sedation, administered a rabies vaccine since we had no idea anything about the other dog, whether they had her vaccine or not. She was, eventually discharged with several medications and was a follow up appointment with Wickaboag. And we kept that appointment on to 2/25. And then there was another follow-up on 3/3 And we kept that appointment. She was on the medications and, she still has the stitches in her back. And the areas of her that they did take pictures of. It was a very, a very traumatic event, for us. Sorry to go on. So, March 5th, I was just 6:30 in the morning. The dog was walking. Luna was walking across our property, headed home. I don't know where she had been, but she was. My dog was, barking out the window. And she just was moving to, moving home. I don't know what that meant. I do feel very strongly, as we said in, that this is a dog has some significant issues. I worry if it should have been a child, God forbid it should be a person. God forbid it should be anybody else. But this is not a safe dog to have in the neighborhood. It changes your whole view of what you value about being in this area. I now walk with pepper spray and I have, I have I'm not sure what you call it, a maglite. If it ever would happen to me again, I wouldn't hesitate to, use the pepper spray and try to defend my dog. I can only tell you that, you know, I don't take lightly, I leave. I feel the same way about dogs, and a lot of people do. But this is just a situation that was unbearable to us. And I feel for all the dogs involved and for the people involved. But it's not a place. It's not a safe. It's not a safe environment if you have something like that, it can happen at any time. And. Thank you. Mr. Sickenberger: What are your vet bills to date What are your vet bills today for the dog? Ms. Nagle: Oh, about $1,500. Mr. Merkel: I'm sorry, I'm sorry for this situation, but is this the second? Ms.Nagle: Yes. This is. Mr. Merkel: Yeah. Okay. So was this reported to the police or animal control? Mr. Sickenberger: You know, this is the one we're actually here for. Ms. Chase: I did not report mine to the police. Mr. Merkel: Yes. Okay. Ms. Chase: I reported this to the dog officer. Kat Mr. Merkel: Okay, All right. Mr. Letendre: She was the second caller on the report of the call that you have there. Mr. Merkel: Okay. First one. All right. Mr. Letendre: May Mr. Sickenberger: Yeah, it was in May. Mr. Merkel: May. Okay. Ms. Nagel: (directed to Ms. Ducharme) And, I have not spoken to you. You have not reached out to me. Our dogs are not friends. You said something about that fact that the dogs were friends. A dog has never met your dog before. Because my dog is always, my dog is always on a leash. And, my dog does not attack, you know, that's the nature of our dog is similar to Louise's. It's a very, a very friendly dog. And and it's a smaller dog Mr. Sickenberger: When you when you walked your dog in the past has you seen Luna? Ms. Nagle: Not that I remember, sometimes, sometimes Luna has been down the driveway, but not when I'm walking the dog. And the dog and the driveway is very long, so, I don't know if, I don't know where she is, but she has been down barking at the street at different times, but I do not believe not they have met. Ms. Chase: And the dog is often in the road. Mr. von Bleicken: Do any of you, police officers, do you have any, anything to add to this? Because, when you were talking before, you were talking about which incident? Mr. Letendre: Hers (referring to Ms. Chase's 2nd call). The dog the second time I got a call was when she saw the dog on the property. Mr. von Bleicken: Okay. Gotcha. I just wanted to clarify. Okay. Is there anyone else who wants to speak? Ms. Murphy: Brid Murphy, 165 Long Hill Rd. I just witnessed that I came running. She called me immediately after calling the police. And I had to run down our driveway. It was. Mr.von Bleicken: I'm sorry. One second. Yeah. Thank you sir. Sorry. Ms. Murphy: Start again? Mr. von Bleicken: Yes, please. Ms. Murphy: My mother called me immediately After getting off of the phone with the cops. She said come down the driveway. Come to the left, you know, come over to that side. 251 Long Hill Road. I came running down the ice coated driveway. I saw my dog and my mom. I went to touch my dog and my hand came away red. She had what looked like a piece of pepperoni on her back. It was the wound. She had multiple wounds on her neck. She was clearly in shock. I can show you a couple of pictures, shortly post-surgery, if you like. They're not great. I'm not great at photography,but this was all what she had to have shaved and stitched. Mr. Sickenberger: She's a black lab? Ms. Murphy: She is a lab hound mix, we're not too sure because we got her from the shelter. That was after the stitching. Yeah, and she's healing. But she also, I don't get good pictures of the back of her neck. It's covered in scars. Do you want to see? Mr.von Bleicken: Anyone else? Okay, I'm going to move them to our, defendant, and any witnesses that you brought. Okay. We'd like to hear your side things. Sure. This said, could you state your name, please? Ms. Ducharme: Addie Ducharme. Thank you. Luna has lived there since we got her. She's almost eight years old. She's a Great Pyrenees, so she does look scarier than... I'm not going to get. You know, they're getting personal, but I don't. Her stature intimidating. And that is her what her breed is about. The times that they're speaking of that she. First of all, if you know Great Pyrenees, they bark, bark bark bark bark, bark. So for them, both of them to say, I don't know, I wasn't there, but I was here with this one. I was at the end of my driveway with the first incident with my son. And that is the reason why Luna did defend us. But she's saying she didn't bark. Luna bark, bark, bark at this dog. She was on our property. She bark, bark, bark until the person. They have a great big tree, oak tree at the end of our driveway, that's our property, but it's also that's where our driveway begins. And then, you know, the gravel of our driveway. Luna, bark, bark, bark until they got around that tree. And then she went to the front of the dog. She did not get the from behind. She pinned him down. My son ran over. We were all in the process of going over there, but she saw me first too. We made eye contact and then my dog came down from the woods, but it was from our neighbors. But it was on to our property and then crossed over. And she's still barking at her. And they continued towards us. And this was, I mean, for the on our driveway or two feet in the road. They were by their oak tree and had to go around the oak tree and our dog that when she came to front of you and that's when she went down on her, she was, you know, fighting, biting. My son went over and did have to pull them off for her because she was holding the dog down. She wasn't biting. She was holding down with her, with her body. She was no longer attacking. She didn't try to go for the throat. She never tried to go for him. It never went for anybody's hand. Never bit my hand. We have chickens. She's never killed a chicken. She never killed a chicken. She's never killed one of the baby chickens we've had. Like I said, they've. And they've stated. And other neighbors that walk their dogs that have never had a problem with them. So they see Luna all the time. They know who she is. Everybody who drives up and down the road. Yes, she is in the road sometimes, and I understand that's my responsibility. So for her to even just say that she's animal lover and to say they're going to euthanize a dog because she injured two dogs and there's not even... I mean, these are flesh wounds. I and I am not...I don't want any animal hurt, but for this to be, they're going to euthanize the dog because of a couple of flesh wounds that were... And you're saying you're not sure what's going to happen? No. Because these these have been for specific times and reasons. That that was the first time I was down there. I'm going to try to keep the dog away from it, it didn't listen to her barks from many barks and barks at her legs and nipped at her legs first. That's what she did. And then she pushed her over. Because you let go of the leash and ran across the road and got down on the dog. Then my son was there and pulled her off. I went over there, and by that time your dog and ran across the street to you like you said. That's because you were across the street. I went over a comforted you, looked at the dog, made sure the dog was not hurt, no signs. The dog was not crying. The dog was not yelping. The dog walked home. I also saw you walking your dog less than three days later when you're not even supposed to have your dog off the property. Ms. Chase: What? Mr. von Bleicken: May I ask that you direct the... Ms. Ducharme: I'm sorry. I'm sorry. I apologize for that. I was walking the dog less than three days after the attack, and the dog was walking, you know, on side of the road. They want to speculate what I'm doing at my house and I mean, I'm not trying to control my dog, but I also try to give my dog freedom and to be able to protect our property. We've had bears on our property, you know, bobcats killing our chickens. It's just. And I'm not saying that's my livelihood. I will happily tie her up if that's, you know, or do anything that obviously would keep her from being euthanized. So I think that's beyond. Beyond angry. The second, the second time I was, it was right. You wouldn't think anybody's walking a dog in the street. It was after three days of storms and I was cleaning off my car to go to work. I... we had a lot of snow. I don't, we don't have a plow. You don't see our driveway because it's rocky. I'm trying to get out there with my little car, my dog out there with me, I get up over the hill and I'm stuck. She comes back to me with blood all over her ears. I don't know what happened. I take her down to my house, which is a walk. Clean it off. I see that there's just a little thing she comes back with some stuff. I'm not sure. I didn't know what happened, so I. I go back and keep trying to get my, finish cleaning my car. I'm trying to get my car up. I get to the top of the hill where I can see the road. I see a black car, but I don't think it must have not been marked, or I just couldn't see because I thought it was our neighbor in the driveway, the black, the police car. So I go back down to my house and then I get a call saying that I need to go talk to the police. So when I get up there before I get up there, I can see my car at the top of the hill. I can't see the road. My dog is sitting next to my car. When I get to there. She goes down there because they're down there, the car, there's three people outside their vehicles and there's two vehicles in the road. So my dog's going...,you know, she's ahead of me. She's going to protect me. Did she bark at them? No. Should she try to go for any person or anything? No. She she sniffed around and as I got closer, downhill, she went across the road and that's what I was yelling to them is she's gonna, she's gonna keep walking. And they want me to come down, talk to them. And I said, if I go down there, she's going to go across the street. I don't want to, you know, because there's the...the road had been plowed so then their cars were in the road. It was a dangerous situation. So I, I was like telling them, just get in your car, my dog will come back and I'll take her home. So that was what I was yelling was about. And then of course, I'm chasing down the road on the other side of the road because she's, you know, that's what she does. She goes, to the cars. So, I'm very sorry that their dogs were injured. I don't want any animal to get injured. See, since the second incident happened, I have been tying her up and I have been letting her off at night just to perimeter her house. But I know that they walk them during the day, and I would tie her up. She's be tied up all day. If it was early in the morning I would get up and tie her up early. And then I was saying that, they said that she didn't know them, but we've had issues before. No, that was the chicken issue. But then, the neighbors did say that Luna would come around their house and they knew her, so they didn't have a problem with her, coming around her house. And there's never been a problem with that. And I'm just trying to say that there's incidents where specific It's because I was near the road. It's not Luna's fault. She. I don't think she would ever, fatally hurt a dog or she have cats. We have, you know, she's docile also. And so I was, you know, you get. It's kind of. I feel like it's kind of like stereotyping here because it was a smaller dog. I don't think I'm going to give any more injuries than not any size dog to. And she was...I know it was scary and I think that's I, I understand your, your, it was very upsetting to see for everybody, but... You need to say the facts that I just don't think she would ever bite a person and so forth. And. I don't think she's dangerous, like, I mean, I think that's really exaggerating her dangerousness. But also beyond that, I did order a system. An invisible, what do you call it? Fence system. Collar system for her, GPS. I mean, I'm trying to look into my research and get, one I think that will work. I just received in the mail yesterday, and I'm charging it up, and I know it's gonna be a lot of training with it, and that's, you know, my responsibility. And I'm going to take it seriously because I would never want to be responsible for, you know, something that is resonsible for me...responsible for her...anything for her. It's she doesn't want to listen, I don't know, I'm sorry that you know...about what happened at all, but I just think there's specific incidents, and that's kinda been blown out of proportion pretty much too. Mr. Sickenberger: How much does Luna weigh? Ms. Ducharme: Probably 75, 80. She's mostly fluff. Mr. Merkel: Has there been barking complaints before? You say she barks a lot. So I mean, have you guys, being neighbors... Have you had issues with the barking or anything like that? Ms. Chase: The dog doesn't bark. Mr. Merkel: Doesn't bark? Ms. Chase: Doesn't bark. The dog did not bark when it attacked my dog. Sergeant Letendre: When I was at the end of the driveway, he was up by the car and he was barking. Ms. Shattuck: She does a typical Pyrenees bark, like, you know, and when she chased her she was, you know, 15ft in front of going woo, woo, woo. That's exactly what they do. They are barkers and they bark more at night than during the day. Mr. Merkel: I'm just trying to figure out I'm not saying if, if, there were other complaints or what has happened. Sergeant Letendre: When I was and it was up by the car it was barking. Mr. Merkel: Okay. Sergeant Letendre: And meant business. Mr. von Bleicken: Yeah. So, so, there's a period of time at this point you can offer questions through the chair or statements through the chair. Direct them to me. Ms. Chase: I certainly was not walking my dog three days later. My dog was torn up. Drain, stitches, the whole nine yards. As I said, very limited activity. Definitely not. I certainly haven't been walking the dog past her house at all. I'm scared to death ever since. Why would I jeopardize my dog's life, okay? Ms. Chase: And I don't think I can get the dog off. She says she's, she would happily tie her up. Well, she's had almost a year to do that. The incident that I had with her was in May 6th. Okay, that's like two months short of a year. And she's been told numerous times. The dog is loose. Tie the dog up. So she's not had to tie the dog up. The dog is in the street. It's during the day. It's down the road. I mean it goes wherever it wants. So she's not had to tie the dog up. She calls these flesh wounds. These are not flesh wounds. These are thousands of dollars worth of damage done to our dogs. These are not fresh wounds. Mr. Merkel: It's a fair question. So, why haven't you tied up your dog after the first incident? Ms. Ducharme: I think that's a because, like I said, it was because I was at the driveway. I was right there. They were coming into our driveway and she bit another dog. I didn't think that relegated her to... Mr. Merkel: What about the second one when your dog came back with blood... Ms. Ducharme: I have been, like I said, Okay, I have been and I did, like I said, I let her out after dark because I know they're not going to walk and nobody's going to be walking their dogs after dark. And I thought that was fair. And I get up in the morning, I'm looking out my window and getting her and calling her and put her in. Mr. Sickenberger: Is she out all the time? Is she out 24 hours a day? Ms. Ducharme: Yeah. If she wants to be...Like, it's yesterday and it's raining, she was on the porch. and then she was inside, then scratching to go out. But I had to keep her on the porch because it was raining out and I don't have a dog house outside for her. So she would be on the porch or inside. Ms. Chase: I just need a couple more things. Okay? Mr. von Bleicken: Don't worry. Ms. Chase: She's acting as if it's my fault that my dog was attacked. It happened the way I said it happened. It happened in front of their neighbor's yard. Not even in front of their yard. My dog is on a leash and on the road. It's not my fault that or my dog's fault. Let's say her dog did growl. It didn't, but let's say it did. Still not my dog's fault that her dog pounced on my dog, flattened her to the ground and tried to, what looked to me like she was going to be killed. That's not my fault. Um, some kind of GPS system? That's not going to help anybody. That's not going to keep me and my dog safe. She's taken it... She says something about taking it seriously. She's not taking it seriously. We had to sue her for God's sake. We called her right after we got out of the veterinary clinic and said how it was. It was serious, and she told us to basically screw, you know, I mean, I'm sorry. She she's had all this time, she's had practically a year to do something. And in the meantime, I don't know how Robin goes out of her door. She's two doors away and the dog's prowling around in her yard. I always walk the other way. I used to go a little ways toward her house until I recently saw the dog again. You know, a half a mile or so from her house. It's not right that I should be penalized because of a dog. Mr. Chase: That's not controlled. Mr. Sickenberger: Have you offered to reimburse the neighbors for their vet bills? Ms. Ducharme: I've not spoken to them at all. Mr. Sickenberger: At all? No contact whatsoever? Ms. Ducharme: No idea what they did. I don't have their phone number. I don't I actually didn't even. I mean they I figured if they wanted to get money they will send something in the mail. I mean I my dog was injured too. Mr. Merkel: Was this incident though, the police spoke with you about it though, with her dog. So, you weren't aware are were you aware? Ms. Ducharme: I knew who it was, but I didn't have their phone number. Mr. Sickenberger: No, but you could have... Sergeant Letendre: I told you the reach out to them though. They're your neighbor. Mr. Sickenberger: Not everything has to come through the chair. And you? Thank you. Ms. Nagle: May I speak? so? Respectfully, the reason why we haven't had, It's just happened a few weeks ago When this happened four weeks ago, we would go through small claims court. As far as I know, there is a process that we have to go through first in order to, you know, expect that we would, want to be, you know, fairly reimbursed. And so we have that process because we just finished the final appointments with the veterinarian. When we went to the veterinarians, both at Wickaboag and Tufts, they were very, very much concerned with the gravity of the, the injuries to the dogs, similar probably to what you experienced. This was nothing superficial. This was nothing. This was life threatening. Obviously, I know you respectfully. You probably understand that when you see it in the first hand, you realize if you don't get your dogs some if you don't get the appropriate treatment, which we were very fortunate, then the dog would die. There was no question. And, and, and like we said, our dog was in, probably traumatized as perhaps your dog was, I'm assuming. And they don't get over that easily. I experienced that today. So when we don't when we don't go out the driveway anymore, we don't go down. We certainly don't take a left. And if we do, we usually drive downtown to go for a walk, which is a sad thing because we live in a wonderful area. And, and so, I also realized that the trauma that the dog suffers doesn't go away readily. And I'm concerned, you know, you know, I obviously we keep our dog in as safe as we can, but her life has changed forever. Our lives have changed, you know, certainly as yours. And, we don't minimize this. We're not. We're not trying to, as I was saying, that this is, Oh, this is, we're making too big a deal of it. The next time, we will not be so fortunate. And. Thank you. Mr. von Bleicken: We have any more questions or comments? Okay, well, then at this point, you can have, if there's a rebuttal or anything more that you wanted to say, before we, deliberate here? Ms. Ducharme: Just like some of the stuff they said was completely false, and she definitely did. She barked. I was there. She barked and barked and warned. And these weren't in front of you saying that they're not comfortable. But I told them there were situations. I was near the road. That's why she tried to keep people away from the driveway. And for them to not give them another chance. And like I said, I'm going to work with her. And it wasn't until the second time happened. I didn't think it would happen ever again. But she would never. She has never and has never shown any signs of hurting a person. So for them, their fear of that, is unrealistic in my opinion. And you can't convince somebody on your fears, when there's no thing to back it up. And if she didn't severely hurt a dog. But, a person. But that's not going to happen because I'm not going to let this happen again. I'm very surprised that we're here, and... Mr. Merkel: I don't think we take this lightly. A lot of people deem their pets like almost their children, right? But, on your on your own admission, when you when you told me I took a note, that your dog comes back routinely with cuts and and wounds that you aren't aware of as I'm walking around that's that's kind of concerning necessarily to me, because if this dog is just running around, you don't know if it's attacking another animal or a child, right? Ms. Ducharme: Yes. So, I mean, I really can't, I can't get behind anything that comes down, goes from an animal to a person, a dog hurting. You can't correlate those. I mean, I wish I could have some backup for somebody that maybe had... I didn't know I was going to have to defend a dog from it. The animal, especially her breed, she's going after small... And, it's probably maybe because it's a smaller dog and she think's it's a possum. Mr. Sickenberger: Actually most dogs are smaller. I actually have a question for a dog, officer. Ms. Shattuck: Okay. Mr. Sickenberger: Once a dog shows aggression like this, does it continue to show aggression? Does it occur more often? Ms. Shattuck: Yeah. Yes. But what I wanted to add was. She is, this is her fault. She's saying, well, they were close to the road and they didn't let me get the dogs. Mass law says they have to be under your control all the time. You can't let them go out in the dark and run all over the neighborhood either. And to speak to the blood moons you probably get, he gets He's probably getting into scrapes a lot because he is doing his job. I have experience with pyrenes, like I said, for 11 years, I love him, I love him. I thought I got him to protect my life, my livestock, when I didn't realize with him is missing a dog. He would just circle our property and bark all night long. So he came in at night and my chickens were killed repeatedly. And until I finally gave up, you know, and even my folks and stuff, I just I just can't have a dog outside running and barking, even in my own yard all night. But she can't just let him. You can't make excuses, you know? I mean, it's not the dog's fault. It's his fault. It's her fault. Mr. Merkel: I don't think the hearing is actually fault. It's more determined whether the dog's a nuisance or a dangerous dog. Ms. Shattuck: Well, he is because he's being allowed to get off his property and not being in control. That's what I'm saying. Not being controlled. It doesn't matter if she's two feet under the, you know, off the road or in the middle of the road. If she can't control him, that's breaking the Massachusetts law. And, you know, this stuff happens once in a while with people's dogs, but only once. You know, usually people don't. they're pretty careful not to let them come out and do it again. And you just keep saying you just can't, you know. Mr. von Bleicken: Is that good? Okay. Ms. Ducharme: I mean. I'm sure I should have like just tied her up 24 seven or something after the first thing that happened. But I mean, I never even got any kind of like saying, like I have to do something, you know what I'm saying? I never got any kind of discipline from anybody saying that you, you know, your dog wasn't on a leash and this is a strike or something like that. Nobody's ever made a concern with her running around. And I understand the concerns are when we were at the road, she and I'm going to say defend. And I'm sorry that they got dogs that hurt more than they. But she was defending and not attacking. And she was warning, and barking, you know? Mr. Sickenberger: How, in your opinion, was she defending for the second incident with the dog? You weren't even near your house. Ms. Ducharme: I was I was up by the driveway and like I said, distance wise, she didn't... she thought I was coming up to the road. If I go on my door, she's ten feet ahead of me thinking where are we going. She's leading me always. And like you said, I didn't think this is my fault. I said that several times, and I'm going to, you know, I'm taking this seriously because I was just told this is I don't know, you know. Yes. The second time, but I had I was and I was looking into what I could do to keep her in the yard better. But after the first time I thought it was, you know, I wouldn't go down by the road unless I had her on a leash and I was. That time I didn't even think of anybody, even, you know, being walking their dog as it was. So when do you couldn't even hear the police officers talking to each other? And we're only 50ft, you know, we're like 75ft away. And we couldn't hear each other because it was so windy and the snow was the snow was blowing everywhere. So, I mean, it's it's not her fault. It is my fault. These are two specific reasons why she did it. We can. It's not like she's erratic. She needs to be controlled and trained. And that's what I plan on doing. And to not let me do that is I just don't think I feel like this with no warning. And if they feel like they've. I've had a lot of warning. I know, Mr. Merkel: So I just have questions for you. For MASS Law, I got to ask you. Ms. Ducharme: Okay. Mr. Merkel: Were you at any point in time too neurotic? Were you teasing, tormenting, battering, assaulting, injuring or otherwise provoking that dog, under oath? Ms. Chase: No Mr. Merkel: Same for you.(directed to Ms. Nagle) You were not teasing, tormenting, battering, assaulting, injuring or otherwise provoking the dog. Ms. Nagle: No. Mr. Merkel: Okay. Ms. Chase: Yeah, I just ask something and I. I wish that Kat Klein were here because she is the dog officer. I have multiple after my incident back in May. So again almost a year ago, two months short of a year, Kat was the person and she was very good. She did get back to me, but she was the person who said, she said, yeah, anytime you see the dog, send me a picture. That, you know, which I would do. I didn't want to, you know, but I did. And Kat told me, I wish that's why we can't reach her. That she would call the defendant and tell the defendant dog is loose. You got to do something. So when she says she didn't know about it, was leaving more time. I'm... It's almost been a year that I've been afraid to walk my dog. It's not right. And she. She doesn't make an attempt to type the dog up. She just doesn't. Ms. Shattuck: One more thing. You can't train a pyr (pyrenes). She could do a huge fence or keep it tied, but you can't train instinct out of a pyr. They're livestock guardians and they're going to continue them. They're just like, they're giving you the middle finger. They don't have a recall. They're just like, I don't think so. I'm going to chase this thing. It's what they do. It's what they're bred for. They're a hard breed, you know? I mean, I have to do things for their families, but they're a half breed, and she's not going to train them. Come home. She comes. Mr. von Bleicken: So, so as a dog officer, my question for you. Is there anything that she can do to prevent, this dog from from, you know, short of being euthanized? Ms. Shattuck: She could fence the property. I don't know if the dog would dig out or not. You know, I don't know this dog's mind. Probably would not have dug out, but, some. I think, you know, his videos of him climbing over fences and stuff. This dog, she's actually nearing the end of her life. They don't live, you know, maybe 11, 12. So I don't know if she could climb at all, but she can fence her property. I mean, she could tie her up, but the dog would be unhappy, tied up all the time because she's not going to be able to do what she wants to do. When you have some, you know, some breeds of dogs just have that really high drive and things different. And pyrenees are one of those breeds. Mr. von Bleicken: Okay. Ms. Chase: If the decision is to let her fence the yard, then we need to know what's going to happen in the meantime. Mr. von Bleicken: Absolutely. Ms.Chase: And seriously, I don't want to talk about euthanasia at all, but it's a dangerous animal. Listen to what she said. Sergeant Letendre:She got one of those invisible fences. It's getting charged right now. Will that work on this dog? Ms. Shattuck: If you're asking me. I mean most likely not. There's a there's a huge hair issue with those breeds, with those collars. First of all, the little prongs have to contact their actual skin. So she's going to have to shave her neck. Second of all, the batteries die. I used to hear all the time, you know. Oh, I'm so sorry. My dog got out the invisible fence. Battery died. And I could easily see a pyrenes, and he's going, oh, it only hurts for a second. And then I'm free, you know, and then maybe deciding not to come back, but, you know, running through that and they are a hard breed. And I love them, but they're a hard breed. Mr. Merkel: Would there...I'm sorry. Would there be a possibility of rehoming? The dog, potentially somewhere. Ms. Ducharme: So I never thought of that, so I dont' know. I mean, I guess that would be, I think, just moving the danger. Mr. Merkel: Yeah. Mr. von Bleicken: Well, if there are no other statements. And it's it's, deliberation time, unfortunately. So, we have to figure out what to do. Mr. Merkel: Do we have an Executive session? Mr. von Bleicken: No. This is going to be an open session. So, my feeling is, personally that, and, you know, I mean, euthanizing the dog is the absolute last resort, but we're getting there. If there's no guarantee that the dog. This is just me, I would like to hear from my cohorts here. I would say that would have to be absolute assurances that this dog was tied up at all times. If it were outside. Inside, of course. But if it's tied up, if it's outside, it's tied up, period. And either that or a, large fence fenced in area. But in the meantime, the dog would have to be tied up. And I am a dog lover. So for me to say this is tough, but, the, the, I mean, the next step and it's really close, this very hard judgment, would have to be euthanizing the dog. So that's just my take. Mr. Merkel: So for for both parties, I mean, going off of this, it's the nuisance, the dangerous dog thing. Mr. Merkel: So, there's a couple things that we have to meet per Mass General Law. Her master wants the dog protecting itself or defending itself, its offspring or another domestic animal or person from attack or assault. Okay, I'm just going to read this out. And the criteria, do I feel that we potentially met that, that that's going to be a tough one to, to, to battle The person who was attacked with, threatened by the dog was committing a crime upon the person, property owner or keeper of the dogs. So if you guys are walking down the street, that doesn't really imply. The person attacker threatened by the dog was engaged in teasing, tormenting, battering, assaulting, injuring or otherwise provoking the dog? By your mission, did you see any of that happen? There is no teasing provoking anything of that sort. Okay, and at the time of the attack or threat of the person or animal that was attacked or threatened by the dog had breached an enclosure structure, which the dog was kept apart from the public and such person, and almost not authorized by the owner of the premises to be within such an enclosure. A gated fenced area, locked or unlocked, provided. However, a person under seven. So, again sounded like it was in the street a public area, not in the in the land. Correct. Let me correct from the two testimonies. So again, I agree with my cohort here. It's I have a big dog. I have a Cane Corso. So I get it. And I and we keep her on a leash when we walk outside because if she went off, she's going to do the same kind of thing, right? She wants to protect her people. However, on a couple of times you mentioned that, you know, you don't think we can't go off a thing, especially when the dog's coming back with injuries that you can't attest to or know what has happened. God forbid it was a child and no one reported it because you live in a rural area, and next thing you know, the police are dealing with a more serious issue, right? I don't want to say that happened to you. I don't want it to happen to anybody or anybody's pets or animals. Correct? The biggest thing I think would be is I think when you're talking about euthanasia, I don't want to put down a dog or anybody's pet or family member at all. But do I feel that, the dog is bordering as, this neutral or dangerous level? It seems like it's going a step up and up. Like Mr. von Bleicken said here. It's it's it's attacked one suspect again. What happens if it was a third time? I don't I don't think we should need it let to to get a third time. And there's certain things that Mass Law is going to have to make you comply with. If we do judge the dog a nuisance or dangerous dog, you're going to have to fence it. You're going to have to hold liability insurance. Is that something that you would be capable of providing if we deem that as a course of action? Ms. Ducharme: Yeah, I would try. I don't know about insurance. Mr. Merkel: There wouldn't be tried. There are things. Ms. Ducharme: I just don't know about insurance, so. I've no idea. I've never looked into that so. I'm going to apply for it. Mr. Sickenberger: In my opinion, this is definitely a dangerous dog. In my experience, once a dog has attacked whether a person or another animal, they tend to get it. I hate to say it, they get a taste for it with intent to do it again. I don't think your collar will work. I have, I have a...probably the most docile dog in the world. I have a 90 pound (?). That dog wouldn't hurt a fly, but we have an invisible fence, and it would walk right through it. I could literally hold it right over the fence, see the collar go. The dog would just look at me like, what man? So I don't think that is a satisfactory solution. And you know, my dogs, people know I've got them. I've put down a 14 year old golden retriever and that killed me. I loved that dog. I love my dogs and I love all humans and, but the risk of of another injury. I think this is, in my opinion, too great. Mr. Merkel: I think you mentioned the breed. We can't go off of them just just being the breed. It has to be the actions of what has transpired. Correct? Mr. Sickenberger: It is the owner's responsibility to control the dog at all times. In the second incident, you know, you, you, you kind of contradicted yourself. You said you always bring the dog on a leash when you're out to the driveway. But then in the second incident, you said it was snowing and the dog was just out you at the top of the driveway and and the dog was protecting you because you, you were nearby, but not I don't think that nearby because you didn't witness the incident. Ms. Ducharme: No, because I didn't think that anyone would be out on the roads, so I didn't. As it was inclement weather. Mr. Sickenberger: But, when when you have a dangerous dog like your dog is and I'm sorry. Ms. Ducharme: Is he? Mr. Sickenberger: You can't, you know, behave like that. I guess. Mr. Merkel: And I don't think nobody wants to see their dog do something, but it seems to be like it's cause injury a couple times now, and it's kind of going on that line. Based off these guidelines I'm naming the dog a dangerous dog. Mr. von Bleicken: Which means. Mr. Sickenberger: Well, if you want to make a motion. Mr. von Bleicken: No, but if you're if you're saying it's over, if it's if it's a dangerous dog, it would. For for this realm, she would have to. The owner/keeper takes remedial action, to, I mean, it's because of nuisance dog. It's just a certain guidelines. I can give her a copy of. Mr. von Bleicken: Basically the decision here is. Mr. Merkel: What we deem it a nuisance or a dangerous dog. Mr. Sickenberger: No. We can we can also order information. A dangerous dog that should be euthanized. That's within our purview. Mr. Merkel: So Hearing Authority deems a dog a dangerous dog, the hearing authority shall order 1 or more of the following: 1) Humanely restrain the dog. 2) Be confined to the premise of the keeper. Confined them indoors or confined outdoors, securely enclosed. 3) When or removed from the premises of the owner, premise of the dog has to be securely, humanely muzzled and restrained with a chain tethering device. Minimum tensile strength around 300 pounds. 4) The owner or keeper of the dog provide proof of insurance, in amount of no less than $100,000 insuring the owner or keeper against any claim or injury to the person. 5) The owner or keeper of the dog provide licensing authority or animal control officer or other entity identified in the order information by which a dog can be identified throughout its lifetime. Microchips. Mr.von Bleicken: I did not read euthanasia. Mr. Merkel: So, it is. It's on number seven that the dog be humanely euthanized. Mr.von Bleicken: Okay. Mr. Merkel: I would, um. Sorry. Ms. Cofske: So you do have the option, you know, to do your your duty tonight certainly, right? Decision on how you deem the dog. And you can certainly take all of this under advisement. Come up with the actions and go forward at a very near date. It's unfortunate that our ACO isn't here, so just letting you know. Mr. von Bleicken: Also, it seems to me we have we have, a decision on the table about either euthanizing or some other, stringent methods like 24/seven, under, being either leashed outside or inside at all times. So, I mean, I've seen that in terms of the fact that it's a dangerous dog, I've seen that of the only two options. Ms. Shattuck: So, yes, you have to consider the anti-tethering laws in Massachusetts now before you move on. They can only be tethered for four hours at a time. And so that dogs need to be watched. Probably won't use a dog house. She probably she needs a dog house. Mr. Sickenberger: So if she's tethered she needs a dog house. Ms. Shattuck: Regardless, actually. When she's outside she needs a dog house. I mean, I don't think she'll probably use the dog house being free or anything like that, right? But by state law, she needs some place to go and for shelter. Mr. von Bleicken: Thank you. Ms. Shattuck: You can only be tethered for up to four hours. Mr. Merkel: I make a motion on the deeming of the dangerous dog for items 2, 4 and 5 if you walk through it. I think was said bases for any further if, God forbid, anything happened she has that insurance policy and then we have to address that matter if that ever did happen again. Ms. Chase: Can I say anything else? Mr. von Bleicken: No. I'm sorry. Mr. Sickenberger: She. I hate to be, the lone voice, but I think the dog should to be euthanized. Mr. von Bleicken: Okay. I, I think that we have to have, an absolute. As far as I'm concerned, it has to be, a, you know, tethered four hours at a time. Whatever you have to do, you would have to have a dog house, built. So you would have to have the dog in at all times. If a violation of of this is seen or happens, that the dog would be euthanized. But, you know, if if that happens, the dog will be euthanized. So my inclination is, is to give that one chance. Mr. Sickenberger: And, so you you're willing to let another dog get hurt or someone get her because there's no way. I'm sorry. There's no way you're going to be able to keep that particular animal tethered or inside the house 24/7. That's it goes, as I have said, that goes against that type of dog. Mr. von Bleicken: That's a point. Mr. Sickenberger: I'm sorry. I really am, I really am. Mr. von Bleicken: Well, it has to be all three of us, you know, doesn't it? Well, no, it has to be. It has to be. It can be. Mr. Sickenberger: It's majority, a majority. So we can make some. One of those can make a motion. And I'm saying, all due respect for this. I don't think we should kick the can down the road. Ms. Cofske: Well I think there needs to be a well, well thought action plan that. Mr. von Bleicken: Actually, I agree with her. I this, this I cannot make this decision to to kill an animal this quickly. Mr. Merkel: Again, I don't want to be, you know, just read everything here. But again, item two. If we ordered this dog secured under these criteria are meet... For me, it's confined to the premises of the keeper provided they are securely confined indoors or outdoors and securely enclosed lock, pen or dog run up on the premise of the owner/keeper provided further that such pen or dog run shall have a secure roof, doghouse or such enclosure has no floor secured to the sides thereof the sides shall be embedded into the ground. If it's basically fenced in in a certain section yard, so I still would protect both the home, just not the exterior portions. The owner shall provide proof of insured for $100,000. Mr. Sickenberger: How much land do you have? Ms. Ducharme: Seven and a half acres. Mr. Sickenberger: So you have to put a fence around the house around seven and a half acres or. Mr. Merkel: Or a portion or a portion of the yard to go for walks. Ms. Ducharme: I can say something about barriers. She was saying if the fence wouldn't work with her, she she doesn't jump or do, Like, we don't have a door on our front porch, and I take the recycle barrel and put it in front, and she doesn't even push it over. Mr. von Bleicken: I'm sorry that the hearing is over. We can't revisit. That's okay. The hearing is over, we can't.. Mr. Merkel: If she goes for a walk, we can pose basically every sanction that Mass General Law would emcompass. Mr. von Bleicken: So I'm inclined to agree with that. I mean, that's that's where I'm leaning because, but if the dog is seen at any point, at any time off leash, you know, I mean, it would have to be an, all or nothing if, I mean, not just attacked another animal, but literally seen off leash.. Mr. Merkel: Yeah, if there's a risk then,because, because.. Mr. von Bleicken: He's right about the fact that, that you cannot take that risk. I'm nervous making, making that choice. I am very nervous making that choice, to be quite honest, because if another animal or, God forbid, a person were attacked, I mean, I would blame, you know, I put blame on myself. And unfortunately, in this position, that's what happens. But for for that reason, if anyone were to see your your dog off leash or, out of your control, then that would have to be, contingent. Ms. Ducharme: Can I say something? Mr. von Bleicken: I mean, it's very clear, everything is very clear here. It's, you know, I mean, it's very thin ice Ms. Ducharme: I'm just seeing with the G.P.S., you can track it and actually see it. Mr. von Bleicken: No. Absolutely not. (referring for Ms. Ducharme to not speak). That's that's just only there's only one way out of this. And in my humble opinion. Ms. Ducharme: I'm just saying also, in case anything comes up, I have regrets. Ms. Chase: What we do in the meantime? Mr. von Bleicken: Well, in the meantime, she's got to be tied up or inside. Mr. Chase: She's not going to do it. Ms. Chase: We are in danger on that road. Mr. von Bleicken: If she doesn't do it, it's. But one picture. Mr. Chase: May I speak? Mr. von Bleicken: Sure Mr. Chase: Did you ever notice when some people are walking with a toddler they might have like a leash on the toddler? What if someone walks by doing that and this dog's... We have one incident. We have another incident that we know of, that we know it. We don't know how many times this may have happened that people just went and got their dog fixed or wasn't. So, in fact, if they're going to be able to, okay, if they're going to build a fence, you know what? You know, if they're going to build a fence... Mr. von Bleicken: I'm sorry, I'm sorry, I can't... Mr. Chase: How long is it going to take to build a fence? Mr. von BLeicken: I'm not going to build the fair hearing. It was over for her. It's it's got to be over for everybody. You know, I'm, I'm, I'm sharing what I feel should happen. But. And the and the option is if you were to able to take one picture of this dog off leash. Mr. Chase: Another one? Mr. von Bleicken: One picture. Ms. Chase: Another one, not the multiple ones we've already taken. We've already done another one. Mr. von Bleicken: Another one off leash. I'm talking about after this hearing, it would be quite easy to do right? to take that picture. Ms. Chase: So, what's the procedure? We take the picture. What happens then? Obviously we don't go through Kat. What do we do? It should be you know I liked Kat. I thought she was very nice. She's not, you know, non-existent at the time. So what do we do? I would say, why call number one again? Mr. von Bleicken: Yeah, I would say call 911 and an email to us. Ms. Chase: And then what happens after that, is an immediate thing? Do they go up and euthanize the dog. I mean, I mean, how how much longer do we have to wait? Mr. Merkel: Even if we judge euthanasia, right. We're not going to go over to the house and say, we'll see you later. Good night. Okay. So, she's has a right to appeal with a district court or any procedure that we issue. Ms. Chase: So this could take months. So months. Mr. Merkel: So, again this hearing was to base on the dog being dangerous and a nuisance and then putting down strict guidelines of what we can do. And I think that's what we're doing. We deemed the dog a dangerous dog. And what needs to be imposed is in effect immediately. But I mean, she still has her rights per applicable General Laws. And that's something that I can't change. Ms. Chase: So, that's still months of being fearful. Mr. Chase: There's no safety. Ms. Chase: Only minimally months for us law abiding... Mr. Merkel: Well, no, we're we're saying with with all these stipulations, this dog is a dangerous dog and it needs to be secured until the fences and everything. Ms. Chase: Then someone needs to take a picture of it, then we have to call 911, get the police involved again, and it comes back to you guys. Mr. von Bleicken: Order Chief Hagglund: Please, the Chair has the floor and everything should be going through the chair. Mr. von Bleicken: Thank you. Ms. Chase: I just want to know what the procedure was. Mr. von Bleicken: Okay. Mr. Sickenberger: I mean, do you want to make a motion? I'm not making this motion. If I may, if I if you want, you can. You want to hear my motion? Mr. von Bleicken:I'd like to take make a motion. You can (referring to Mr. Merkel). So we need to have a motion. Mr. Merkel: So I would like to make a motion that we deem the dog a dangerous dog. Per that motion, as the hearing authority that the dog be humanely restrained. Mr. Sickenberger: Can we do this in two motions? We have a motion to deem the dog a dangerous dog. Mr. Merkel: I make a motion to deem the dog a dangerous dog. Mr. Sickenberger: So I'll second. All those in favor? Aye, Aye -unanimous Mr. Merkel: Can I make a motion for the terms being the hearing authority Sections 1, 2, 3, 4 and 5 be imposed on the owner effective immediately. Mr. Sickenberger: If I can second the motion. So I'll second that motion. Mr. von Bleicken: Okay. All in favor. Let's, you want to move to a roll call? Eric von Bleicken - Brad Merkel- aye; Eric von Bleicken - aye; Roland Sickenberger - aye. So, the decision is then that that,that this dog will be restrained at all times, no more than four hours and brought him inside all the time. If the dog is off leash at any time by anyone, and the picture was taken, then we were going to re-vote, We're going to, obviously re-vote and change it to, to euthanize. Okay, any questions? Mr. Merkel: I'm making a copy of what I/we proposed. Ms. Nelson: Okay. I have a question. If they can't get a picture of it, but they see it off of her property, will you take their word for it? Mr. von Bleicken: Well, we will we will definitely take their word for it, especially if there's more than one person that sees it. Mr. Merkel: Yeah, I would. Call the police. Everything's audio video recorded and documented. Sergeant Letendre: We have bodycameras. Ms. Chase: If the dog is unleashed and on her property? Mr. von Bleicken: If the dog is, is unleashed and even on her property, unsecured. Mr. Merkel: Unsecured. Here, again, our police are audio and video recorded. They write a report, Ms. Chase: I'm sorry I just want to go over the procedure again. Once we get the picture of the dog, we will go to a 911 call. Right? And then it comes back to the board, comes back to you guys to discuss it again. Mr. Merkel: Do you want me to read the guidelines? Ms. Chase: No, and that you would have to have another hearing and after the hearing and then or there and then she can still go. She can still say, no, no, no. I mean, is it a definitive decision at that point. Mr. Sickenberger: The hearing would be similar to tonight. Mr.von Bleicken: But under different circumstances. Ms. Chase: So but let's, let's just say we get to the point. You say yes, dog needs to be euthanized. Is that the final decision or does she have a right to appeal at that point? Mr. Sickenberger: She has a right to appeal, so then it can continue. It goes to the court. Ms. Chase: In the meantime, the dogs. We've come because we have situation and I don't I don't want to euthanize the dog either. You know? Ms. Shattuck: It's a harsh thing to say. But if that dog is off the property, attacking the police they have the right to do it. Mr. von Bleicken: Yeah. Mr. Merkel: And if any of these are violated, ma'am, you know, we have the authority to impound the dog and hold it and to check. Okay? Ms. Chase: Who checks if the dog's been tied up. Mr. von Bleicken: Anyone that's there, can. Ms. Chase: I mean, is anybody going to, you know, like law enforcement would have to follow up to make sure. Oh, yeah the dog is being tied up or we're just assuming that she's going to. Mr. von Bleicken: Well, I would ask that question of law enforcement. Chief Hagglund; Usually respond to calls for service. That would be if the dog was not tied up. Right. We're just assuming we're not the, you know, minority report police when we're trying to do crimes before they happen. I think that would be up to the patrol officer to ensure compliance. Okay? Mr. Merkel: And I do see you guys' concerns, but I'm trying to look at the side of both sides. If you were sitting in her shoes, would you want someone demanding your dog be euthanized? I'm trying to I'm trying to I'm trying to. Ms. Chase: I would have done something within that year, within that ten months. Mr. Chase: And there would not have been a second attack. Mr. von Bleicken: Well, this is this is a last chance. Ok. I would like to close the hearing at 7:55pm. So thank you, everyone, for coming. Everyone: Thank you. Ms. Chase: Thank you for listening.